SALT LAKE COUNTY
Hurt in Utah? Free consultation with a Utah personal injury law firm, and you don’t pay unless we win.
Alta is a town of a few hundred residents at the top of Little Cottonwood Canyon. On a good powder day it holds thousands of people. All of them arrive on the same state highway, park in the same handful of lots, and walk across the same stretch of packed snow in ski boots. That geography shapes almost every injury claim that comes out of this town.
Alta is also unusual legally. Most Utah injury cases start with a car and a police report. Here, a serious injury is just as likely to involve a person on skis, a bus full of passengers, or a road that the state closes by order when the avalanche danger climbs.
The only road to Alta. It climbs steeply through terrain UDOT describes as carrying 64 avalanche paths, with more than half the highway threatened by slides. Add hard-pack ice, tight curves, and drivers looking up at the slopes instead of at the car ahead, and you get rear-end collisions, slide-offs and head-on crossings over the center line.
Storm mornings back traffic out of the canyon gate and down onto Wasatch Boulevard. Fast valley traffic meets a stopped queue with no warning. This is textbook rear-end and lane-change territory, and it is where a great many Alta-bound trips end badly before the driver ever reaches the mountain.
The Wildcat and Goldminer's Daughter lots put pedestrians, ski buses, shuttles and reversing cars in the same small space, on snow, in low light. Low-speed impacts here still break bones. Pedestrians crossing between a bus stop and a lodge are hit by drivers who never saw them against the snowbank.
In summer the dirt road up to Albion Basin and Cecret Lake fills with wildflower traffic. It is narrow, dusty, has no shoulder and no separation between vehicles and the hikers, cyclists and children walking on it. Blind curves and drivers watching the scenery produce a different set of crashes than winter does.
The Skiing Act Shields the Resort. It Does Not Shield the Skier Who Hit You.
Utah's Inherent Risks of Skiing Act (Utah Code § 78B-4-401 and following) says a person who skis may not recover from a ski area operator for injuries caused by risks that are an integral part of the sport. The statute's definition of those risks is broad: changing weather, snow and ice conditions as they exist or change, surface and subsurface conditions such as rocks, stumps and trees, variations and steepness in terrain including terrain parks and features, impact with lift towers and other structures — and collisions with other skiers. Read quickly, that list sounds like the end of every ski injury claim. It is not. The bar protects the operator. It does not make the skier who ran into you immune, and it does not excuse an operator's own negligence, which is a separate question from an inherent risk. Sorting which of those two things happened to you is usually the first real decision in an Alta case.
If you were hurt in a vehicle crash on SR-210 or at the canyon mouth, your own auto policy pays first, regardless of who caused it. Personal injury protection covers at least the first $3,000 of medical bills and 85% of lost wages, under Utah Code § 31A-22-307. That money is meant to start immediately. It is not a settlement, and accepting it does not decide fault.
Three thousand dollars does not go far after a canyon crash. One ambulance ride down Little Cottonwood, an emergency department visit and a single scan can exhaust it. Once your medical expenses pass $3,000, you may step outside the no-fault system and make a claim directly against the driver who caused the crash. You may also step outside it, under Utah Code § 31A-22-309, if the injury caused permanent disability or permanent disfigurement, a bone fracture, dismemberment, or if someone was killed.
One thing to be clear about: no-fault is a motor vehicle rule. It does not apply when a skier collides with you on the hill, or when you are hurt by a hazard inside a lodge. Those claims run against the person or business responsible, and health insurance, not PIP, usually pays the bills in the meantime.
Utah divides fault by percentage under Utah Code § 78B-5-818. Your recovery is reduced by your own share of the blame, and if you are found 50% or more at fault, you recover nothing at all. There is no partial credit at that line. It is a wall.
In Alta this is the argument the other side reaches for first, because the setting makes it easy to try. You were driving too fast for the conditions. You should have had better tires. You skied out of a side trail without looking uphill. You crossed the road between buses instead of at the marked crossing. You were on the road when the canyon was posted for storm conditions. Each of those is a percentage the insurer wants to hang on you, and each one is worth real money to them.
The evidence that answers those arguments is perishable. Snow melts and is groomed over. Lift and gate scan records, resort incident reports, ski patrol notes, canyon traffic camera footage and bus system data all exist on retention schedules measured in weeks or months. Getting them requested in writing early is often the difference between a shared-fault fight you win and one you lose.
Deadlines You Cannot Miss
Most injury claims from a vehicle crash must be filed within four years (Utah Code § 78B-2-307). A wrongful death claim must be filed within two years. And if a government entity is involved — UTA, a city or county vehicle, UDOT, or an unrepaired road hazard — you have only one year to file a notice of claim under the Governmental Immunity Act. That one-year rule matters more in Alta than in most places, because so much of what happens here involves a state highway, a transit bus, or a public agency's decision about the road.
Someone comes into you from above at speed and leaves. These cases turn on identifying the other skier, on witnesses who were on the same run, and on the uphill skier's duty to take reasonable care. The Skiing Act does not decide them. Fault does.
Rear-end impacts in slowed traffic, slide-offs on ice, and crossings into oncoming traffic on the climb. Whether a driver had required traction devices, and how long the road had been in that condition, both matter to the case.
Passengers are hurt when a bus brakes hard, when a shuttle is struck, or while boarding on a snow-covered shoulder. A UTA bus brings the Governmental Immunity Act's one-year notice deadline into play immediately, which is why these cases cannot sit.
People walking in ski boots between lots, lodges and bus stops are hit at low speed by drivers with iced windows and poor sightlines over snowbanks. Low speed does not mean minor: knees, hips, wrists and heads take the impact.
Untreated ice on lodge steps, unlit stairwells in nightly rentals, and loose dogs in the base area. Utah applies strict liability to dog owners, so an owner is generally responsible for a bite whether or not the dog had ever bitten anyone before.
Alta sits in Salt Lake County, so a lawsuit arising here is filed in the Third Judicial District Court at the Matheson Courthouse, 450 South State Street, in Salt Lake City. Most claims settle without a filing, but a case is only ever worth what it is worth if the other side believes you are prepared to go there.
This page is general information about Utah law, not legal advice about your situation. Every case turns on its own facts. Past results do not guarantee a future outcome.