Short answer: In Holmes v. Smith, a 2026 rear-end crash case, the Utah Court of Appeals ordered a new trial. It held that a defense doctor should not have been allowed to call the collision “low speed, low impact” without first showing he had a reliable method for judging crash speed. It also held that free workplace help from an employer does not reduce what the at-fault driver owes, and that medical records need a proper foundation before a jury can rely on them.
Photos of a bumper with little visible damage are often the first thing an insurer points to when it says an injury could not have come from the crash. This decision does not stop that argument. It does set limits on who can make it to a jury as an expert, and on what evidence the defense can use to shrink the damages.
What Happened
The case is Holmes v. Smith, 2026 UT App 89, decided June 4, 2026. In October 2017, Emily Holmes was stopped in a construction zone in West Point when Catherine Smith’s car hit her from behind.
Holmes was 36. She had scoliosis but did not know it, because it had never caused symptoms. After the crash she was diagnosed with sprain and strain injuries in her neck and lower back and treated from November 2017 through May 2018. Then there was a gap until August 2018, when she went back for pain.
The defense built its case around that gap. Smith argued the crash caused only a temporary injury that resolved, and that the later symptoms came from the scoliosis and two degenerative discs in Holmes’s neck. The jury found Smith negligent and awarded Holmes economic and noneconomic damages totaling more than $60,000. Holmes appealed, arguing that several trial rulings kept the jury from seeing the case fairly. The Court of Appeals agreed on four of them.
A Doctor Needs a Method Before Calling a Crash “Low Impact”
The defense medical expert was an orthopedic surgeon. At his deposition he admitted he had no training in estimating impact speeds from photographs, that he was “not a biomechanics person,” and that he had no scientific method for it. At trial he told the jury the collision was “very low impact,” based on photos of the cars and Holmes’s own description of the crash. The trial court allowed it as a general description.
The Court of Appeals held that was an error. Because the opinion came from an expert, it had to satisfy Utah Rule of Evidence 702, which requires a threshold showing that the opinion rests on reliable principles or methods, reliably applied. There was no showing that the surgeon had expertise in accident reconstruction, biomechanics, or anything else that would let him estimate speed or force from pictures. As the court put it, a medical expert may rely on patient history for diagnosis and causation, “[b]ut that principle does not extend to offering independent conclusions about the mechanics of a collision without a reliable foundation.”
Free Help From an Employer Does Not Shrink Your Damages
Holmes’s life care planner recommended an ergonomic evaluation and a sit-stand desk. Her employer had already given her one. The trial court excluded that part of the plan, reasoning that letting her recover the cost of something she was getting free would be unfair.
The Court of Appeals reversed. Utah’s collateral source rule prevents an injured person’s recovery from being reduced because someone independent of the wrongdoer has paid for or provided part of the loss. Relying on Utah Supreme Court precedent, including the 2025 decision we discuss in what Gardner v. Norman means for your claim, the court said the rule applies even when it gives the injured person a windfall, because the injured person, not the person who caused the harm, should get the benefit. The court also noted that Holmes might change jobs, or her employer might stop providing the accommodation.
The trial court had also cut testimony from the life care planner because her cost figures ran past her own estimate of how many years Holmes would keep working. The Court of Appeals said those were alternative calculations the jury could use if it found a longer work life, and that questions like that go to the weight of the testimony, not whether the jury may hear it.
Medical Records Need a Proper Foundation
The defense offered Holmes’s medical records through her own medical expert, who admitted he did not know who created them, when the entries were made, or how they were stored. The trial court admitted them anyway, partly because Holmes had agreed the records were authentic.
The Court of Appeals held that was not enough. Under Utah Rule of Evidence 803(6), business records like medical charts come in only when a records custodian or another qualified witness, or a proper certification, shows how they were made and kept. Agreeing that records are what they claim to be is different from agreeing that every entry in them is admissible to prove what it says.
What the Court Did Not Decide
Holmes also argued the jury should have been told that Smith had the burden to prove how much of the harm came from the pre-existing conditions. The court agreed that the principles in her proposed instruction reflect Utah law, which lets an injured person recover for the aggravation of a prior condition. But the trial court refused the instruction because no evidence of aggravation had been presented, and Holmes never asked for a narrower version. Because the argument she made on appeal was not raised at trial, the court did not decide it.
The ruling also does not say the crash caused Holmes’s later symptoms, and it does not bar “low impact” arguments. Photos of the vehicles can still come in, and a properly qualified expert with a reliable method could still offer an opinion about the collision. The case goes back for a new trial, and a new jury will decide the facts. As of September 2026, we found no later appellate decision changing this ruling, though a Court of Appeals decision can be reviewed by the Utah Supreme Court.
What This Means for Your Claim
- Light vehicle damage is not the end of the question. An opinion about crash speed or force has to come from someone qualified to give it, using a reliable method.
- Gaps in treatment get used against you. The defense theory in this case was built on a three-month gap. If you are still hurting, keep your appointments and tell your doctors.
- Accommodations are part of the loss. A special desk, modified duties, or other help an employer provides can still count in the damages claim.
- A prior condition is not a bar, but aggravation has to be proven. Usually that means a medical opinion that ties the worsening to the crash.
We explain how Utah handles fault in these crashes in who is at fault in a rear-end collision in Utah, and how neck and back injuries are proven in whiplash and soft-tissue injury claims. For pre-existing conditions and noneconomic damages, see pain and suffering damages in Utah. Most Utah injury lawsuits must be filed within four years (Utah Code 78B-2-307(4)).
Talk to a Utah Car Accident Attorney
When an insurer says a crash was too minor to hurt anyone, the answer is usually in the medical records and in holding the other side’s experts to the rules. A free consultation is a good time to look at both.
Hurt in Utah? Call (801) 921-5134 or send us your case for a free consultation. No attorney fees unless we win. Hablamos Español.

