Skip to main content
Office Mon–Fri 8:00 AM–6:00 PM · Free consultation · Hablamos Español

Underinsured Motorist Claims in Utah: The Coverage You Already Paid For

Underinsured Motorist Claims in Utah: The Coverage You Already Paid For

Most people who call us after a serious crash assume one policy decides what their case is worth: the one belonging to the driver who hit them. That policy is usually the ceiling on what the at-fault driver’s insurer will pay. It is rarely the ceiling on what is available.

When the Other Policy Runs Out — or Was Never There

Utah sets a floor, not a realistic number. For policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2025, minimum liability coverage is $30,000 for injury to one person, $65,000 per accident, and $25,000 for property damage (Utah Code 31A-22-304). Policies written before that date can still sit at the old $25,000 floor.

Thirty thousand dollars does not go far. An ambulance ride, an emergency room workup, imaging, and a few months of physical therapy can reach it before anyone has mentioned a surgery or a missed year of work.

When the at-fault driver’s coverage cannot fully compensate you, that vehicle is legally an “underinsured motor vehicle,” and your own underinsured motorist coverage — UIM — becomes available (Utah Code 31A-22-305.3). The test counts “all special and general damages” (31A-22-305.3(1)(b)(i)), from bills and wages to pain and lost quality of life; see our guide to damages in a Utah personal injury case.

A separate coverage, uninsured motorist or UM, applies when there is no policy to collect from at all. Utah defines “uninsured” more broadly than most people expect. It includes the hit-and-run driver who was never identified, a driver whose insurer disputes coverage for more than 60 days, and a driver whose insurance company is declared insolvent (Utah Code 31A-22-305). That claim has its own rules, covered in how an uninsured motorist claim works in Utah and hit and run in Utah.

Utah Adds UIM on Top. It Does Not Subtract.

This is the part that surprises people, and it is worth getting right.

In many states, underinsured motorist coverage is reduced by whatever the at-fault driver already paid. Utah does the opposite. UIM “may not be set off against the liability coverage” of the at-fault driver, and instead “shall be added to, combined with, or stacked upon” it (Utah Code 31A-22-305.3(3)(k)(ii)).

In practice: if the at-fault driver tenders a $30,000 policy and you carry $100,000 in UIM, you are looking at $130,000 of available coverage — not $100,000.

There is a second surprise waiting on your own declarations page. For new policies written since January 1, 2001, UIM limits equal the lesser of your liability limits or the highest UIM limits your insurer offers under the policy, unless a named insured signed an acknowledgment form rejecting UIM or choosing less (Utah Code 31A-22-305.3(3)(b)). Adding or removing a named insured, or changing liability limits, counts as a new policy (31A-22-305.3(3)(a)). UIM cannot be sold below $10,000 per person (31A-22-305.3(3)(i)), and drivers who assume they carry that minimum frequently carry several times that. Pull the declarations page and look before you assume.

How Utah underinsured motorist coverage stacks Utah Code section 31A-22-305.3(3)(k)(ii) forbids setting underinsured motorist coverage off against the at-fault driver's liability coverage and instead adds it on top, while section 31A-22-305.3(4)(a)(ii) forbids stacking the underinsured motorist limits of two or more of your own vehicles. UTAH CODE § 31A-22-305.3 How Utah Underinsured Motorist Coverage Stacks It is added on top of the at-fault driver's policy. It is never added to your own second car. IT STACKS On top of the at-fault driver YOUR DAMAGES $250,000 AVAILABLE TO YOU $130,000 $30,000 at-fault $100,000 your UIM $120,000 uncovered § 31A-22-305.3(3)(k)(ii) — UIM “may not be set off against” the at-fault policy; it is “added to, combined with, or stacked upon” it. IT DOES NOT STACK Across your own vehicles YOUR CAR 1$100,000 + YOUR CAR 2$100,000 $200,000 → $100,000 Two or more vehicles “may not be added together, combined, or stacked.” § 31A-22-305.3(4)(a)(ii) ONE EXCEPTION A pedestrian struck by an underinsured vehicle — and certain other covered persons — may reach the highest limits of one additional policy per household. § 31A-22-305.3(4)(b)(i), (vii) 01 You probably already have it UIM is in your policy unless you affirmatively waived it in writing. § 31A-22-302(1)(c) 02 The floor is very low UIM cannot be sold below $10,000 per person. At-fault minimum: $30,000. § 31A-22-305.3(3)(i); § 31A-22-304 03 The clock is not the crash date Four years to sue on UIM, running from the check for the last liability payment. § 31A-22-305.3(5)(a), (5)(b)
Swipe to see the full diagram →

Who Can Claim UIM, and Under Which Policy

UIM protects “covered persons” (31A-22-305.3(1)(a)): the named insured, dependent minor children, relatives living in the household, anyone occupying a vehicle referred to in the policy, and anyone entitled to recover for the injury or death of one of them (31A-22-305(1)).

Two limits apply. If you are hurt in a car owned by or furnished to you, your spouse or a resident relative, UIM pays only if the policy describes that car or covers it as a new or replacement vehicle (31A-22-305.3(2)(b)). And a car owned by a named insured, a spouse or a dependent is not an “underinsured motor vehicle” under that household’s own policy (31A-22-305.3(1)(b)(ii)).

You also cannot add together the UIM limits on several of your vehicles for one accident, and someone hurt in a vehicle described in a policy with UIM generally cannot also collect UIM under another policy (31A-22-305.3(4)(a)). The exceptions (31A-22-305.3(4)(b)):

  • A pedestrian struck by an underinsured vehicle may recover under one other policy on which they are a covered person.
  • Someone hurt in a car not owned by or furnished to them, their spouse, or a resident parent or sibling may also claim under one other policy.

Total recovery can never exceed your full damages, though a policy outside the auto-policy rules, such as an umbrella, may add coverage on its own terms (31A-22-305.3(7)).

The Order of Payment: PIP, Then Liability, Then UIM

UIM is the last layer. The statute makes it “secondary to the liability coverage” of the at-fault driver (31A-22-305.3(3)(k)(i)).

  • PIP first. Personal injury protection pays at least $3,000 in medical expenses per person regardless of fault (Utah Code 31A-22-307). To claim pain and suffering from the at-fault driver, you need more than $3,000 in medical expenses or a listed injury such as a fracture or permanent impairment (Utah Code 31A-22-309(1)(a)). See is Utah a no-fault state?
  • The at-fault policy next. Since May 6, 2026, a policy-limits demand to a liability insurer in a third-party claim must include enough information to evaluate the claim and allow at least 30 days to respond (Utah Code 31A-22-323). It addresses third-party liability claims, not the UIM claim against your own insurer. More in what a policy-limits demand is in Utah.
  • UIM last. It covers the damages that remain, up to your UIM limit.

Because UIM pays what you are “legally entitled to recover” from the at-fault driver (31A-22-305.3(2)(a)), the usual damages rules apply. You recover only if the other side’s fault exceeds yours, and your share reduces the recovery (Utah Code 78B-5-818). With health insurance, past medical expenses are measured by the negotiated amount the insurer’s contract required, not the hospital’s gross charge (Gardner v. Norman, 2025 UT 47).

Settling With the At-Fault Driver Without Losing UIM

Utah once had a waiting period here: after the at-fault insurer tendered its limits, the UIM carrier had five business days to waive subrogation or pay the tendered amount itself. The Legislature repealed that procedure in 2018 (S.B. 190). Now a UIM insurer “does not have a right of reimbursement” against the at-fault person once that person’s insurer “has tendered the policy limit and the limits have been accepted by the claimant” (31A-22-305.3(6)).

That rule covers a full-limits tender; settling for less needs a separate look. Your policy may impose its own notice conditions, so tell your insurer in writing that a UIM claim may follow before anything is final. And read the release: it should cover the at-fault driver and that driver’s insurer, not your rights under your own policy.

The Deadline Is Not the Crash Date

A Utah personal injury claim generally has to be filed within four years of the injury (Utah Code 78B-2-307). A UIM claim runs on its own clock.

The period is still four years, but it starts later. The “inception of loss” is the date of the settlement check representing the last liability policy payment (Utah Code 31A-22-305.3(5)). UIM is secondary coverage by design: the at-fault policy resolves first, and only then does the UIM clock begin. If you choose arbitration, the claim counts as filed when you submit it (31A-22-305.3(8)(d)).

The later UIM clock does not extend the claim against the driver. A wrongful death action has two years (Utah Code 78B-2-304), and if the driver was a government employee on the job, a notice of claim is due within one year (Utah Code 63G-7-402). See our Utah statute of limitations guide.

Two more rules matter if you were working when you were hurt. The workers’ compensation carrier cannot subrogate against UIM, though UIM will not pay again for a benefit comp already provided (Utah Code 31A-22-305.3(4)(c)). Health insurance subrogation is permitted only after you have been made whole.

Arbitration or a Lawsuit Against Your Own Insurer

If the UIM claim does not settle, you generally choose binding arbitration or litigation, though a policy may let the insurer elect it (31A-22-305.3(8)(a)–(b)). Once you sue, switching to statutory arbitration takes the insurer’s written consent. An arbitrator cannot award more than the combined UIM limits, decides no coverage or bad-faith questions, and is not told your limits (31A-22-305.3(8)(l)–(m), (9)(f)). Either side can demand a new trial within 20 days of the award, but risks paying the other side’s costs if the verdict does not move far enough (31A-22-305.3(8)(p)–(r)).

Within 30 days of electing either path, the claimant must send a written demand with a specific amount, a sworn five-year disclosure of providers and health insurers, and records authorizations (31A-22-305.3(9)(a)). The insurer has up to 60 days to respond and tender what it thinks it owes, which you may take as full or partial payment. If the final award beats the average of the demand and that response, the insurer pays it, up to its limits plus $15,000, with certain costs (31A-22-305.3(9)(c)–(g)).

What to Do Now

  • Collect the declarations page for every auto and umbrella policy in your household.
  • Open your PIP claim right away.
  • Give your own insurer written notice of a possible UIM claim.
  • Do not accept less than the at-fault limit, or sign a release, until the UIM effect is clear.
  • Calendar every deadline, including four years from the last liability check.

Common Questions

I was a passenger in a friend’s car. Whose UIM applies?

The friend’s UIM pays first. If the car was not owned by or furnished to you, your spouse or a resident parent or sibling, your own UIM can follow as secondary coverage (31A-22-305.3(4)(b)(ii), (v)).

Does my UIM insurer have to approve my settlement with the at-fault driver?

The statute no longer sets an approval window, and accepting the full liability limit cuts off the UIM insurer’s reimbursement claim. Still, give written notice first.

I turned down UIM years ago. Is that still binding?

A rejection stays in place with that insurer until a named insured asks in writing for a change, but it must be on a department-filed form that explains UIM and discloses the premium for full limits (31A-22-305.3(3)(b)–(c)). Ask to see the signed form.

Talk to a Utah Car Accident Attorney

If you were told the at-fault driver’s policy was the end of the conversation, it may not have been. An attorney reviews every case at intake and approves every demand and settlement, and once you sign, the firm handles all communication with the insurance companies, including your own. Learn more about our Salt Lake City car accident attorneys.

Hurt in Utah? Contact West Injury Law for a free consultation by phone, video or in person. You pay nothing up front, and no attorney fees unless we win. Hablamos Español.

Free Case Review

Hurt in Utah? Get a free case review. No attorney fees unless we win. Hablamos Español.