Skip to main content
Mon–Fri 8:00 AM–5:00 PM · Free consultation · Hablamos Español
(801) 921-5134 Español
Free Case Review
Menu
Close

Another Lawyer Said My Case Isn't Worth Much. Can I Get a Second Opinion?

Short answer: Yes. You can ask another lawyer to look at your case at any point, and a free consultation costs you nothing. A second look sometimes turns up something the first one missed: another insurance policy, a fuller injury picture once treatment is done, or a better answer on fault. Sometimes it confirms the first lawyer was right. Either way, you want that answer before you sign a release or let a deadline slip past.

How a lawyer actually decides what a case is worth

Case value is not a single guess. It comes from three separate questions, and a low opinion usually traces back to one of them.

1. Liability: can fault be proven?

Someone else has to be legally responsible, and it has to be provable with evidence rather than just your account. Utah uses modified comparative fault. Under Utah Code 78B-5-818, you can recover only from a defendant whose fault exceeds yours, and your share of fault reduces what you receive. A crash where the other driver says you ran the light, and there is no witness or video, is worth less than a clear rear-end collision with the same injuries.

2. Damages: what did the injury cost you?

That covers medical expenses, lost income, future care, and the effect on your daily life. For car crashes, the no-fault threshold in Utah Code 31A-22-309(1) matters too: pain and suffering against the at-fault driver is available only if the injury crosses it, for example by medical expenses above $3,000, a fracture, or a permanent impairment based on objective findings. A valuation made early in treatment may simply be a valuation of an unfinished injury. See damages in Utah personal injury cases.

3. Coverage: is there money to collect?

This question is the one people most often overlook. A case can be worth far more than the insurance behind it. For policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2025, Utah's minimum bodily injury liability limit is $30,000 per person under Utah Code 31A-22-304. If the at-fault driver carries the minimum and has no assets worth pursuing, that limit can cap a practical recovery, unless other coverage exists. Underinsured motorist coverage on your own policy, or a household member's, is often where a second look finds room.

When the low opinion is probably right

Be ready to hear that the first lawyer was correct. That is a real outcome, and it is better to learn it from someone with no stake in signing you. A modest valuation is often accurate when:

  • The injury resolved in a few weeks, the bills stayed under the threshold, and PIP paid them.
  • The evidence puts as much fault on you as on the other driver.
  • The other driver has minimum limits, you have no underinsured coverage, and nobody else shares responsibility.
  • A filing deadline has already passed.

A lawyer can also decline a case for reasons that have nothing to do with whether you were hurt, such as the cost of experts compared to the available coverage. Ask the first lawyer which of the three questions drove their opinion. A clear answer tells you a lot.

When a second look is worth it

  • The value was estimated while you were still treating, or before a new diagnosis.
  • Nobody asked about your own auto policy or policies held by people in your household.
  • The opinion leaned heavily on photos of light vehicle damage. See when the insurer says your injuries are minor.
  • You were never told why the case was worth little, only that it was.
  • Something has changed since: surgery was recommended, you could not return to work, or a witness turned up.

What to bring to a second-opinion consultation

  • The crash report and any photos.
  • Declarations pages for your auto policy and any household policies.
  • A list of providers, and any bills or records you have.
  • Letters or emails from any insurer, including offers.
  • Any fee agreement you signed, and the first lawyer's letter declining or valuing the case.

If you already hired the first lawyer: how switching works

You are allowed to change lawyers. The comment to the Utah rule on terminating representation, Rule 1.16 of the Utah Rules of Professional Conduct, states that a client may discharge a lawyer at any time, with or without cause, subject to liability for payment for the lawyer's services. Rule 1.16(d) requires the lawyer to provide the client's file on request.

In practice the new firm usually handles the handoff. If a lawsuit is already on file, Utah Rule of Civil Procedure 74(e) lets new counsel replace the old through a notice of substitution signed by the former lawyer, the new lawyer, and the client.

The first firm may be owed something for its work. Utah's attorney's lien statute, Utah Code 38-2-7, gives a lawyer a lien on a settlement or judgment in a matter the lawyer worked on, whether or not the lawyer still represents the client when the money comes in. When a contingency case changes hands, the earlier firm's claim is generally measured by the reasonable value of the work it did (often called quantum meruit), plus any costs it advanced. Ask the new firm to explain in writing how that claim will be handled before you switch.

Changing lawyers late in a case costs time, so it should be a considered decision. If your lawyer is the one ending the relationship, see what to do when your lawyer drops your case.

How we handle a second-opinion call

An attorney reviews every case at intake, including ones another firm has already looked at. We will tell you what we see, including when we agree with the first opinion. If we take the case, you pay nothing up front, and no attorney fees unless we win. The fee is one-third of the recovery, and the firm advances case costs, which are repaid from the recovery (see how fees work). For questions worth asking any firm, see choosing a personal injury lawyer in Utah.

Common questions

Is it all right to get a second opinion while I have a lawyer?

Yes. It is your case. You do not need your current lawyer's permission to talk with another one, and the consultation stays confidential.

Does a second opinion cost anything?

Not here. The consultation is free, and there is no obligation to hire us.

Can a settlement calculator tell me if the first number was fair?

It can give you a rough sense of the moving parts. Our settlement calculator shows which factors push value up or down, but it cannot see your records, your coverage, or the proof on fault.

Does the deadline pause while I look for another lawyer?

No. Most injury claims must be filed within four years under Utah Code 78B-2-307(4), and claims involving a government entity need a notice of claim within one year. See the Utah statute of limitations guide.

Get another set of eyes on it

If a lawyer has told you your case is small and the answer did not sit right, our legal team will take a look and tell you plainly what we think. Call (801) 921-5134 or send us your case. Free consultation. No attorney fees unless we win. Hablamos Español.