Short answer: Most Utah personal injury lawyers work on a contingency fee, which means you pay nothing up front and the lawyer is paid a percentage of what is recovered. If there is no recovery, there is no attorney fee, but case costs are a separate question your written agreement has to answer.
Cost is one of the first things people worry about after an injury, usually while the bills are already arriving. Here is how the arrangement actually works in Utah, and what to look for before you sign anything.
How a Contingency Fee Works
A contingency fee is contingent on the outcome. The lawyer takes on the case without an hourly bill or a retainer, and the fee comes out of the settlement or verdict as a percentage of the recovery.
That structure is what makes representation possible for most injured people. You do not need savings to hire a lawyer, and the lawyer has a direct reason to pursue the full value of the claim, because the fee grows only if the recovery does.
Percentages vary from firm to firm and sometimes change depending on how far the case goes. A claim that settles early is less work than one that goes through a lawsuit, depositions and trial, and many agreements reflect that. Ask for the numbers in writing, at every stage.
Why Injury Cases Are Rarely Billed by the Hour
Many lawyers bill by the hour against a retainer paid in advance. That fits poorly after an injury: the injured person is often missing work while bills arrive, and no one can say at the start how many hours a claim will need. A contingency fee moves that uncertainty to the lawyer, who carries the time and expenses and is paid only from a recovery.
The Agreement Must Be in Writing
Utah does not leave contingency fees to a handshake. Under Utah Rule of Professional Conduct 1.5(c), a contingent fee agreement has to be in a writing signed by the client. It must state the percentage the lawyer receives in the event of settlement, trial or appeal, which litigation expenses will be deducted from the recovery, and whether those expenses come out before or after the fee is calculated.
The rule also requires the agreement to clearly tell you about any expenses you will owe whether or not you win. And when the case ends, the lawyer has to give you a written statement of the outcome showing how your share was calculated.
If a lawyer will not put those terms on paper, that is your answer.
Attorney Fees Are Not the Same as Case Costs
This is the distinction people most often miss. The fee pays for the lawyer’s work. Case costs are the out-of-pocket expenses of building the claim: court filing fees, service of process, medical records and billing records, police reports, deposition transcripts, and expert witnesses such as physicians or accident reconstructionists.
In most injury cases the firm advances these costs and is repaid from the recovery. That is how we work at West Injury Law: our fee is one-third of the total settlement, calculated on the gross amount before case costs are deducted, and we advance the case costs as the case goes, which are then repaid from the recovery at the end. Your written agreement sets out exactly how both are handled.
Whichever firm you hire, two questions decide what the cost terms mean for you:
- Are costs deducted before or after the fee is calculated? On the same settlement, the order changes the amount you take home.
- Who pays the costs if the case is lost? That depends entirely on your written agreement, which is exactly why Rule 1.5(c) requires it to say so.
Where the Costs Come From
Before a lawsuit, costs tend to be modest: copy charges for medical and billing records, and crash reports. Filing suit changes that. The district court fee to file a complaint seeking $10,000 or more is currently $375 under the Utah courts’ filing fee schedule, and that is one of the smaller items. Serving defendants, court reporters and deposition transcripts, mediation, and above all expert witnesses can add up quickly in a contested case. The steps in a Utah personal injury case show when each stage arrives.
Fee on the Gross, or Fee After Costs
Contingency agreements figure the fee in one of two basic ways. Under the first, the percentage is applied to the gross recovery and the advanced costs are repaid afterward. Under the second, the costs come off first and the percentage is applied to what remains. The second leaves the client more by the fee percentage times the costs, so the gap grows as costs do. Utah law does not require either method; Rule 1.5(c) requires the agreement to say which one applies, and the signed agreement controls. Our sample settlement statement runs one hypothetical settlement both ways, line by line.
One Utah Cap: Medical Malpractice
For most injury claims, Utah law does not set a maximum percentage. Medical malpractice is the exception. In a malpractice action against a health care provider, an attorney may not collect a contingent fee greater than one-third of the amount recovered, whether the case resolves by settlement, arbitration, judgment or appeal (Utah Code 78B-3-411).
Outside malpractice there is still a limit, just not a fixed number. Rule 1.5(a) forbids an unreasonable fee or an unreasonable amount for expenses, weighing factors such as the time and skill the work requires, the results obtained, and whether the fee is fixed or contingent.
What You Actually Take Home
The settlement figure is not the number that reaches your bank account. From the gross recovery come the attorney fee, the case costs, and any amounts owed to those who paid for your care.
In a Utah car crash, your own personal injury protection coverage pays the first medical bills regardless of fault, with a minimum of $3,000 in medical benefits (Utah Code 31A-22-307). Beyond that, a health insurer, Medicare, Medicaid or a hospital may assert a lien or a right to reimbursement from the recovery. Those claims are often negotiable, and reducing them is part of the work that determines your net.
If you want a rough sense of what a claim might be worth before those deductions, our settlement calculator walks through the main factors.
The Order Money Moves When a Case Resolves
- Trust account. The check is deposited in the law firm’s client trust account. Rule 1.15 requires client money to be kept separate from the firm’s own, prompt notice when funds arrive, and a full accounting on request.
- The attorney fee is paid as the written agreement provides.
- Advanced costs are repaid.
- Liens and reimbursement claims are paid at their final amounts, often lower than first asserted; any amount still in dispute stays in trust until resolved.
- Your net is paid to you with the written closing statement.
Which Claims Come Out of Your Share
PIP usually does not. If another driver caused the crash, your PIP carrier looks to that driver’s liability insurer for repayment rather than to your settlement, disagreements between them go to binding arbitration, and the right ends if the liability insurer has tendered its policy limit (Utah Code 31A-22-309(6)).
Health plans often do. What a health insurer can recover depends on the kind of plan and the wording of its documents; self-funded employer plans governed by the federal ERISA law tend to hold the strongest repayment rights. See medical bills and liens after a Utah accident.
Medicare must be repaid. Federal law treats Medicare’s accident-related payments as conditional and requires reimbursement from a recovery (42 U.S.C. 1395y(b)(2)). In a disputed claim, Medicare generally reduces its claim by a proportional share of the fees and costs of obtaining the recovery (42 C.F.R. 411.37).
Providers paid at the end. A clinic that treated you on a lien is paid from the settlement under the terms you signed, so read treating on a lien in Utah first. A Utah hospital’s statutory lien reaches only the patient’s portion after attorney fees, court costs and other expenses of obtaining the recovery (Utah Code 38-7-1).
If the Case Does Not Win
Under a contingency agreement, no recovery means no attorney fee. Whether you owe anything toward advanced costs depends on your written agreement, which Rule 1.5(c) requires to say so clearly.
A filed lawsuit adds a separate risk. A court can order the losing party to pay the winner’s taxable court costs (Utah Rule of Civil Procedure 54(d)(1)), which are not the expenses your own lawyer advanced. And if you decline a formal offer of judgment and the adjusted award is no more favorable, you pay the defense’s costs incurred after the offer (Rule 68(b)).
Questions to Ask Before You Sign
- What is the percentage if the case settles before a lawsuit, after a lawsuit is filed, and if it goes to trial or appeal?
- Are case costs deducted before or after the fee?
- If we lose, do I owe anything for costs?
- Who negotiates medical liens and reimbursement claims, and is there a separate charge for it?
- Will I receive a written closing statement showing every deduction?
A good lawyer will answer each of these plainly, and the answers will match what is in the agreement.
Common Questions About Injury Lawyer Fees
Does the fee apply to the money that repays my medical bills?
Under most contingency agreements the percentage applies to the whole recovery, including the part that ends up repaying medical bills. That is why lowering liens and reimbursement claims has such a direct effect on your net.
Who decides whether to accept a settlement?
You do. Rule 1.2(a) requires a lawyer to abide by the client’s decision whether to settle, and a fee agreement does not change that. The lawyer’s job is to explain the offer and your likely net.
Is a lower percentage always the better deal?
Not necessarily. What you keep also depends on whether the fee is figured before or after costs, and on how far liens and reimbursement claims are reduced. For more on judging a lawyer beyond the fee, see how to find a good personal injury lawyer in Utah.
Talk to a Utah Personal Injury Attorney
The consultation itself should cost nothing, and it is the right time to ask every one of these questions. Ours are free, by phone, video or in person. You can read more about how we handle personal injury claims in Salt Lake City and across Utah.
Hurt in Utah? Contact West Injury Law for a free case review. No attorney fees unless we win. Hablamos Español.

